| Year | Award Organization | Artist | Album | Song Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | GMA Dove | Laura Story, Christopher Stevens, Bryan Fowler | Till I Met You | |
| 2002 | GMA Dove | Michael W. Smith, Lenny LeBlanc, Paul Baloche | Above All | |
| 1997 | GMA Dove | Bob Carlisle, Randy Thomas | Butterfly Kisses | |
| 1992 | GMA Dove | Bob Farrell, Greg Nelson, Sandi Patty | For All the World | |
| 1991 | GMA Dove | Bruce Carroll, C. Aaron Wilburn | Who Will Be Jesus? | |
| 1990 | GMA Dove | Steven Curtis Chapman, Jerry Salley | His Strength Is Perfect |